Payment method display statistics for defaults and hidden options
https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/payment-method-display-statistics-for-defaults-and-hidden-options/
## Quick answer
Payment method display statistics show why a change in method mix needs interpretation. In a European Commission commissioned experiment, 39% of respondents switched to a method suggested by the display practice between two tasks, while 12% switched to another method. The scenario used hypothetical purchases, with no personal money spent (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
This analysis separates those outcomes, checks the display practices' unequal promoted sets and explains why the missing second-task untreated group matters. The merchant decision is whether a changed layout helps shoppers complete payment or simply steers selection. Selection, preference and completed orders remain distinct throughout the analysis.
## Key Takeaways
39% switched to a display-suggested payment method. Another 12% chose a different nonsuggested method between the two experimental tasks (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
Show-more promoted three alternatives, not one. Its roughly 80% suggested-switch result therefore has a broader outcome definition than defaults or upstreaming (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
The study did not observe payment completion. Participants made hypothetical selections and were told they would not spend their own money (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
## What does a payment mix change actually establish?
A payment method can gain share because it became easier to select or because another method became harder to find. Selection data do not by themselves reveal a new shopper preference or an increase in completed orders.
Figure description: Payment method display statistics economic sensitivity: with 20% of completed orders shifting methods, savings of $0.50,$1 and $2 per shifted order allow approximately 0.266,0.530 and 1.053 percentage points of completion loss before contribution falls.
Figure 1: A cheaper method mix allows only a bounded completion loss. Source: Commission report, selection-versus-completion scope (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025. Original explanation and arithmetic from the cited primary research.
### How was the experiment constructed?
The European Commission commissioned report used an experimental module within its consumer survey. Participants first selected a payment method from a randomized vertical list. In a second task they received one of three display practices: an earlier purchase button for another method, a different preselected default, or a show-more menu hiding the previously chosen method. The module planned 800 respondents per country, split into roughly 266 per treatment (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
Participants selected among methods reflecting their reported ownership, and the scenario required no real personal spending. The experiment therefore observes payment selection in a hypothetical purchasing task, not approval, authorization or settlement.
### What changed between tasks?
The report summarizes 39% of respondents changing to a method suggested by the display practice and 12% changing to an unsuggested method. Adding the rounded figures gives approximately 51% switching by either route and a residual 49% not switching. Those are our arithmetic summaries of reported rounded shares, without a new raw-data estimate (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
The average selected position moved from 4.38 to 3.73, or 0.65 positions nearer the top. These are ordinal positions. A percentage change in list position would not be a meaningful improvement in payment completion.
## Can the three display techniques be ranked as conversion tools?
The reported selection outcomes differ, but their definitions and experimental controls prevent a simple conversion ranking. The source itself explains these limits.
### Why is show-more not a like-for-like comparison?
The summary describes roughly four out of five respondents choosing a suggested method under show-more, compared with 22% under defaults and 15% under upstreaming. Show-more counted any of three visible alternatives as suggested, while the other conditions promoted one. That gives show-more more possible outcomes in the success category (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
The report says the difference between default and upstreaming was not statistically significant. We therefore do not describe the 22% versus 15% figures as a proven seven-point advantage. Their rounded gap can be read descriptively, with the reported uncertainty retained.
### What does the missing control change?
All participants received a display practice in the second task. There was no second-task group with the original display repeated unchanged. The report explicitly says it cannot compare switching with its likelihood in the absence of a display practice (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
Random assignment among practices can inform comparisons among those practices. It does not identify how many of the total between-task switches would have occurred anyway. Repeating a hypothetical shopping task can itself change a respondent’s choice, so the whole 51% cannot be assigned to the display intervention.
## How should a merchant evaluate a payment layout?
Keep shopper access and successful completion visible in the decision. A higher wallet share can lower processing cost yet create more abandoned or failed payments. A better decision uses method choice, payment failures, completed paid orders and contribution together.
### What comparison would answer the merchant’s question?
Include the current display as a concurrent control and preserve a clear route to every legitimately available method. Define the promoted set consistently across conditions. If a layout hides a shopper’s previously chosen option, measure the effort needed to recover it and whether the shopper still completes.
### What should a team avoid inferring?
Do not equate a selected logo with actual method availability or a successful payment. Country, currency, order value and provider eligibility can alter the final set. Keep those conditions consistent where possible and report their exclusions. The public experiment provides evidence about choice architecture, with explicit limits. It does not justify concealing options or claiming a checkout uplift from a change in method mix.
## How much completion loss could erase a cheaper method mix?
A worked fee model shows why payment share is an intermediate result. Assume 10,000 eligible attempts,80% completing, and $30 contribution per completed order after the current expected fees. If a display shifts 20% of completed orders to a method saving $1 each, contribution per completed order rises to $30.20. The baseline is $240,000. The changed layout must retain a completion rate of at least 0.80 ×30 /30.20, approximately 79.470%, to preserve that amount.
The allowed decline is therefore about 0.530 percentage points of attempts. At 79.5% completion, the model gives $240,090. At 79.4%, it gives $239,788. The same improved method mix can accompany either a small gain or a loss. These are explicit worked assumptions, not fees, purchase rates or outcomes observed in the Commission's hypothetical selection exercise.
### Which part of the cost calculation needs the payment outcome?
A selected method may fail authorization, lack actual eligibility or require another authentication step. Apply the fee schedule to successfully completed transactions under the provider's real charging rules, and retain failed-attempt costs where applicable. A share change among selections cannot identify fee savings per attempt without those later events.
The worked model assumes the shifted share remains 20% of completed orders, no change in order value, a constant $1 saving and no extra implementation or failure costs. At savings of $0.50 or $2 per shifted order, the maximum modeled completion-rate decline changes to about 0.266 or 1.053 percentage points. A store's real schedule may have fixed fees, percentage fees and order-value interactions that require a transaction-level calculation.
### How should a fair display comparison be defined?
Keep the current layout as a concurrent control, use the same legitimately available method set and define the promoted set consistently. Measure method selection, authorization, final paid orders and contribution on the same assignment rule. Preserve access to the shopper's preferred method instead of counting a forced switch as success.
The source's roughly 80% show-more result counts three suggested options, while the 15% upstreaming and 22% default results promote one. Dividing 80 by three would not create a fair per-option effect, because choices among the options are not independent and the display changes the choice set. Likewise, the report's missing unchanged-display second task prevents estimating how much switching would have happened on repetition alone. (European Commission commissioned research (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf), Jun 2025).
A successful local result therefore needs more than a changed logo share. It needs preserved access and an outcome that survives fees, failures and completion changes. The fee-versus-completion sensitivity (https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/payment-method-display-statistics-for-defaults-and-hidden-options/data/payment-display-economics.csv) and calculation (https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/payment-method-display-statistics-for-defaults-and-hidden-options/analysis.py) make that threshold explicit while leaving the public experiment's actual selection findings unchanged.
## Methodology and Sources
We downloaded the 2025 final report for the European Commission and read the design on printed pages 120 to 123 and outcome discussion on 179 to 181. Its publication was released 18 June 2025; fieldwork dates are retained as the report’s own scope rather than invented from the release date. The CSV transcribes reported rounded shares and average ordinal positions. Our arithmetic adds 39% and 12% and takes their complement, plus the 4.38 minus 3.73 position difference. We do not estimate causal switching versus no display practice because the second task has no untreated group. The study’s roughly 80% show-more figure has three suggested options; its 15% and 22% comparisons promote one. No payment-completion effect is calculated.
## Glossary
Default: An option selected before the shopper makes an active choice.
Upstreaming: Presenting a payment shortcut before the usual checkout selection.
Promoted set: The options counted as suggested by a display practice.
Payment completion: A successful payment outcome, distinct from selecting a method.
## Sources
European Commission commissioned research: Market study on competition in online payments, final report (https://www.learlab.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/kd0125004enn_online-payments_study.pdf)
Quick answer
Payment method display statistics show why a change in method mix needs interpretation. In a European Commission commissioned experiment, 39% of respondents switched to a method suggested by the display practice between two tasks, while 12% switched to another method. The scenario used hypothetical purchases, with no personal money spent (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
This analysis separates those outcomes, checks the display practices' unequal promoted sets and explains why the missing second-task untreated group matters. The merchant decision is whether a changed layout helps shoppers complete payment or simply steers selection. Selection, preference and completed orders remain distinct throughout the analysis.
39% switched to a display-suggested payment method. Another 12% chose a different nonsuggested method between the two experimental tasks (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
Show-more promoted three alternatives, not one. Its roughly 80% suggested-switch result therefore has a broader outcome definition than defaults or upstreaming (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
The study did not observe payment completion. Participants made hypothetical selections and were told they would not spend their own money (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
A payment method can gain share because it became easier to select or because another method became harder to find. Selection data do not by themselves reveal a new shopper preference or an increase in completed orders.
Figure 1: A cheaper method mix allows only a bounded completion loss. Source: Commission report, selection-versus-completion scope, Jun 2025. Original explanation and arithmetic from the cited primary research.
The European Commission commissioned report used an experimental module within its consumer survey. Participants first selected a payment method from a randomized vertical list. In a second task they received one of three display practices: an earlier purchase button for another method, a different preselected default, or a show-more menu hiding the previously chosen method. The module planned 800 respondents per country, split into roughly 266 per treatment (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
Participants selected among methods reflecting their reported ownership, and the scenario required no real personal spending. The experiment therefore observes payment selection in a hypothetical purchasing task, not approval, authorization or settlement.
The report summarizes 39% of respondents changing to a method suggested by the display practice and 12% changing to an unsuggested method. Adding the rounded figures gives approximately 51% switching by either route and a residual 49% not switching. Those are our arithmetic summaries of reported rounded shares, without a new raw-data estimate (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
The average selected position moved from 4.38 to 3.73, or 0.65 positions nearer the top. These are ordinal positions. A percentage change in list position would not be a meaningful improvement in payment completion.
The reported selection outcomes differ, but their definitions and experimental controls prevent a simple conversion ranking. The source itself explains these limits.
The summary describes roughly four out of five respondents choosing a suggested method under show-more, compared with 22% under defaults and 15% under upstreaming. Show-more counted any of three visible alternatives as suggested, while the other conditions promoted one. That gives show-more more possible outcomes in the success category (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
The report says the difference between default and upstreaming was not statistically significant. We therefore do not describe the 22% versus 15% figures as a proven seven-point advantage. Their rounded gap can be read descriptively, with the reported uncertainty retained.
All participants received a display practice in the second task. There was no second-task group with the original display repeated unchanged. The report explicitly says it cannot compare switching with its likelihood in the absence of a display practice (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
Random assignment among practices can inform comparisons among those practices. It does not identify how many of the total between-task switches would have occurred anyway. Repeating a hypothetical shopping task can itself change a respondent’s choice, so the whole 51% cannot be assigned to the display intervention.
Keep shopper access and successful completion visible in the decision. A higher wallet share can lower processing cost yet create more abandoned or failed payments. A better decision uses method choice, payment failures, completed paid orders and contribution together.
Include the current display as a concurrent control and preserve a clear route to every legitimately available method. Define the promoted set consistently across conditions. If a layout hides a shopper’s previously chosen option, measure the effort needed to recover it and whether the shopper still completes.
Do not equate a selected logo with actual method availability or a successful payment. Country, currency, order value and provider eligibility can alter the final set. Keep those conditions consistent where possible and report their exclusions. The public experiment provides evidence about choice architecture, with explicit limits. It does not justify concealing options or claiming a checkout uplift from a change in method mix.
A worked fee model shows why payment share is an intermediate result. Assume 10,000 eligible attempts,80% completing, and $30 contribution per completed order after the current expected fees. If a display shifts 20% of completed orders to a method saving $1 each, contribution per completed order rises to $30.20. The baseline is $240,000. The changed layout must retain a completion rate of at least 0.80 ×30 /30.20, approximately 79.470%, to preserve that amount.
The allowed decline is therefore about 0.530 percentage points of attempts. At 79.5% completion, the model gives $240,090. At 79.4%, it gives $239,788. The same improved method mix can accompany either a small gain or a loss. These are explicit worked assumptions, not fees, purchase rates or outcomes observed in the Commission's hypothetical selection exercise.
A selected method may fail authorization, lack actual eligibility or require another authentication step. Apply the fee schedule to successfully completed transactions under the provider's real charging rules, and retain failed-attempt costs where applicable. A share change among selections cannot identify fee savings per attempt without those later events.
The worked model assumes the shifted share remains 20% of completed orders, no change in order value, a constant $1 saving and no extra implementation or failure costs. At savings of $0.50 or $2 per shifted order, the maximum modeled completion-rate decline changes to about 0.266 or 1.053 percentage points. A store's real schedule may have fixed fees, percentage fees and order-value interactions that require a transaction-level calculation.
Keep the current layout as a concurrent control, use the same legitimately available method set and define the promoted set consistently. Measure method selection, authorization, final paid orders and contribution on the same assignment rule. Preserve access to the shopper's preferred method instead of counting a forced switch as success.
The source's roughly 80% show-more result counts three suggested options, while the 15% upstreaming and 22% default results promote one. Dividing 80 by three would not create a fair per-option effect, because choices among the options are not independent and the display changes the choice set. Likewise, the report's missing unchanged-display second task prevents estimating how much switching would have happened on repetition alone. (European Commission commissioned research, Jun 2025).
A successful local result therefore needs more than a changed logo share. It needs preserved access and an outcome that survives fees, failures and completion changes. The fee-versus-completion sensitivity and calculation make that threshold explicit while leaving the public experiment's actual selection findings unchanged.
We downloaded the 2025 final report for the European Commission and read the design on printed pages 120 to 123 and outcome discussion on 179 to 181. Its publication was released 18 June 2025; fieldwork dates are retained as the report’s own scope rather than invented from the release date. The CSV transcribes reported rounded shares and average ordinal positions. Our arithmetic adds 39% and 12% and takes their complement, plus the 4.38 minus 3.73 position difference. We do not estimate causal switching versus no display practice because the second task has no untreated group. The study’s roughly 80% show-more figure has three suggested options; its 15% and 22% comparisons promote one. No payment-completion effect is calculated.
Use the citation below when referring to this analysis. Source populations and calculation limits accompany each finding.
Checkout Closer. "Payment method display statistics for defaults and hidden options." Checkout Closer, November 2026. https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/payment-method-display-statistics-for-defaults-and-hidden-options/
<a href="https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/payment-method-display-statistics-for-defaults-and-hidden-options/">Payment method display statistics for defaults and hidden options</a> (Checkout Closer, November 2026)