BNPL Approval Statistics and the Counteroffers Behind Them https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/bnpl-approval-statistics-and-the-counteroffers-behind-them/ ## Quick answer CFPB’s six-lender administrative series shows BNPL application approval rising from 56% in 2019 to 79% in 2022. Approvals include counteroffers, which may require a larger down payment or a smaller financed amount. The report separately estimates that counting counteroffers as approvals adds about 8 percentage points to the overall 2022 approval rate in that comparison. A merchant needs the accepted terms and current order state to know whether the original cart can proceed. (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). An approval label can conceal a revised down payment, a lower financed amount or a further acceptance step. This reference follows the CFPB’s annual series and its separate counteroffer discussion, then connects those definitions to the state of a saved cart. The analysis preserves the report’s approximate estimates and distinguishes an application outcome from a completed merchant order. ## Key Takeaways CFPB reports 56% of BNPL applications approved in 2019 and 79% in 2022, a 23-percentage-point increase in its six-lender series (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/consumer-use-of-buy-now-pay-later-and-other-unsecured-debt/), Jan 2025). The annual approval series is 56%, 67%, 78% and 79% for 2019 to 2022. The final annual increase is 1 percentage point (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/consumer-use-of-buy-now-pay-later-and-other-unsecured-debt/), Jan 2025). CFPB estimates that the overall 2022 approval rate is approximately 8 percentage points higher when counteroffers are counted as approved (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/consumer-use-of-buy-now-pay-later-and-other-unsecured-debt/), Jan 2025). The report describes counteroffers that require a larger down payment or a reduced financed amount (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/consumer-use-of-buy-now-pay-later-and-other-unsecured-debt/), Jan 2025). ## Which approved amount can the shopper actually use? A shopper returns to a saved checkout after choosing pay in four. The lender has offered finance, but the offer covers less than the shopper requested. If the cart and terms have changed, a recovery reply that simply says the payment is approved can leave the customer facing the same obstacle again. Figure description: BNPL approval interpretation tree: check the financed and upfront amounts, acceptance state and current cart identity before treating an approval as an actionable payment. Figure 1: An approval still leaves three facts to resolve. Source: CFPB, counteroffer definition (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025. Original analysis of the cited source. Source periods and calculation limits appear in the text. CFPB’s research shows why the approval label needs context. Lenders may respond with a counteroffer that increases the down payment or reduces the credit amount. A lender can therefore record an approval while the shopper still needs to decide whether the revised terms work for them. For a merchant support team, the useful fields are the requested amount, the amount offered, the required payment now, the acceptance state and the current cart. Those fields explain what the shopper can do next. A broad approval statistic cannot replace them. ## How did reported approval rates change from 2019 to 2022? The six-lender series reports 56% of applications approved in 2019, 67% in 2020, 78% in 2021 and 79% in 2022. The increase from the first to the last year is 23 percentage points. (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). The annual steps are uneven. Approval rose 11 points from 2019 to 2020 and another 11 points from 2020 to 2021. It rose 1 point from 2021 to 2022. These comparisons describe the published series, including the definition used to count approvals. (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). The composition of applications also matters. The same person may apply repeatedly, and the people applying can change across years. Treating the series as evidence that any given shopper became 23 points more likely to qualify would erase those differences. (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). ## How did counteroffers change the approval measure? The report says counteroffers were used relatively little in 2020. By 2022, they were increasingly used across credit-score categories. In the report’s overall comparison, counting counteroffers as approved applications raises the 2022 approval rate by approximately 8 percentage points. (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). That estimate helps explain why an approval statistic can rise while some shoppers still face a meaningful decision. A larger upfront payment may be unaffordable for the purchase they intended. A smaller financed amount may require removing products or paying the difference through another supported method. The source’s 79% annual figure and approximate 8-point comparison should retain their own definitions. Subtracting 8 from 79 to produce an exact 71% no-counteroffer rate would imply that both numbers came from an identical unrounded sample. The report does not justify that reconstructed precision. (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). ## How should a changed offer affect the recovery reply? Consider a $120 cart and a financing request for that purchase. If the returned offer requires more upfront cash than the shopper expected, the conversation has become a question about the accepted payment schedule. If the financed amount is lower, the question may concern the cart total or the remaining balance. The agent should use the actual terms visible to the shopper and explain the supported next step. It should also let the customer decide whether to continue. Assuming they want another credit application, a more expensive payment route or a reduced order would add a preference they have not expressed. A pending offer creates another branch. It may still require acceptance or a step in the provider’s flow. Asking the customer to pay again before checking that state can create confusion about whether they have already committed to a purchase. ## How are lender outcomes different from checkout outcomes? An application, an offer, an accepted offer, an authorized payment and a completed order are different events. A merchant evaluating recovery needs a definition for each. Otherwise a helpful financing reply can be credited with a sale before the store has an order, or blamed for an incomplete purchase while the provider is still processing a decision. An operational review can follow a single attempt from the requested cart through the provider response to the eventual order. Retain the response that was available when the message was sent. A later approved state should not silently replace an earlier pending response in the record. For an experiment, count the customer’s completed order as the purchase outcome and preserve any cancellation or refund treatment chosen in advance. Keep application approval as a separate intermediate result. This makes it possible to identify where the customer’s path changed without stretching one event into the whole journey. ## What can a DTC brand infer from these figures? The data support asking a better question before explaining an approval. It shows that revised terms are part of the reported approval measure, and that their inclusion can materially affect the percentage. It does not measure a particular brand’s financing availability, the terms available to its shoppers or the effect of its recovery messages. Those depend on the provider response, current cart, market and shopper circumstances. A store that already receives a final accepted approval for an unchanged cart may not face the counteroffer ambiguity on that attempt. Use this research to define the state your team must check. Describe the actual offer accurately, give the shopper space to choose and measure the final store outcome separately. That is the useful connection between a national lender study and a specific checkout conversation. ## Which source figures support the findings? The table retains the source measure and its population. Independent results in the next table use the stated formula; their precision follows the recorded inputs. Source measure | Value and unit | Population or denominator Approval 2019 | 56 % of applications (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025) | Raw provider application sample; includes counteroffers Approval 2020 | 67 % of applications (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025) | Same reported annual series Approval 2021 | 78 % of applications (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025) | Same reported annual series Approval 2022 | 79 % of applications (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025) | Same reported annual series 2022 counteroffer accounting difference | About 8 percentage points (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025) | Overall approval is approximately 8 points higher when counteroffers count as approvals 2019 to 2022 approval change | 23 percentage points (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | Different annual applicant mixes, no causal trend claim 2020 to 2021 approval change | 11 percentage points (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | Reported annual approval rates 2021 to 2022 approval change | 1 percentage point (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | Reported annual approval rates ### How were the additional comparisons calculated? These are calculations from the source inputs. Each retains its original unit and comparison population. Calculation | Result | Formula 2019 to 2022 approval difference | 23 percentage points (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | 79-56 2019 to 2020 approval difference | 11 percentage points (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | 67-56 2020 to 2021 approval difference | 11 percentage points (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | 78-67 2021 to 2022 approval difference | 1 percentage point (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, independent analysis (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Nov 2026) | 79-78 ## How can the same cart require a different payment today? A worked allocation makes the counteroffer problem visible. Assume an unchanged $120 cart, no fees or interest, an upfront payment followed by three equal later payments, and financing that covers only the later payments. With $90 financed, the upfront amount is $30 and the later amounts are $30 each. With $75 financed, the shopper needs $45 today and three later payments of $25. With $60 financed, the upfront amount rises to $60 and the later payments fall to $20 each. Worked offer | Amount financed | Due upfront | Each of three later payments Initial allocation | $90 | $30 | $30 Smaller financed amount | $75 | $45 | $25 Further reduced financing | $60 | $60 | $20 These are accounting examples, not lender quotations or reported CFPB terms. They illustrate the report's mechanism: an approved counteroffer can reduce later financing while increasing the cash needed to finish the original purchase. The $75 case requires 50% more upfront cash than the initial $30, even though the cart total has not changed. (CFPB, counteroffer mechanism (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf), Jan 2025). ### Which state makes a saved approval unsafe to reuse? The amount and cart identity must travel with the response. A provider offer for $120 cannot by itself authorize a later $135 cart after shipping, tax or a product change. Likewise, an accepted offer and a pending counteroffer are different states even when their quoted amounts match. The recovery system should identify the current cart version, the terms actually returned and whether the shopper accepted them before it describes the next step. A useful implementation check tries four cases: unchanged cart with accepted terms, unchanged cart with an unaccepted counteroffer, changed cart with an earlier accepted offer, and no final provider response. Only the first case establishes that the known offer matches the current cart and has been accepted. It still does not establish captured funds or a completed store order. This is an operational state test derived from the event distinctions above, not a new national approval rate. ### What comparison would separate clearer explanations from more lending? Hold the provider's returned offer fixed when testing an explanation of revised terms. Compare clear presentation of total, upfront amount and later amounts with the existing presentation, and preserve a route to decline or choose another legitimately available method. Measure accepted terms and completed orders separately. If lender eligibility, cart price and explanation all change together, an order increase cannot identify the explanation's contribution. Counterevidence matters. A store whose provider already returns a final accepted offer for an unchanged cart may gain little from another clarification step. A new panel could add effort without resolving any ambiguity. The public counteroffer evidence supports checking whether that ambiguity exists; it does not justify adding steps to every checkout or steering a shopper toward more borrowing. The worked cash allocation (https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/bnpl-approval-statistics-and-the-counteroffers-behind-them/data/counteroffer-cash-allocation.csv) and calculation (https://checkoutcloser.com/guides/bnpl-approval-statistics-and-the-counteroffers-behind-them/analysis.py) retain all assumptions. The approximate national counteroffer comparison remains separate from these examples and is not subtracted from the rounded annual 79% series. ## What a partial refund does to the payment plan An approval shows what the shopper could use at checkout. After a return, the provider’s posting record answers a different question: what does the shopper still owe? Take a $100 US order. The shopper paid $25, leaving $75 on the plan before the merchant sends a $60 refund. A $60 credit to the plan leaves $15. A separate $60 credit to the shopper’s PayPal account leaves the plan balance at $75. These examples exclude interest and fees. Where a $60 refund goes and what the shopper can verify Refund route | What posted | Remaining plan balance in this example | What to check before replying PayPal credits the plan | PayPal shows the refund posted to this Pay in 4 loan. | $15 | Check the remaining dates and amounts in the plan. PayPal credits the account | The $60 went to the PayPal account because PayPal could not identify the plan. | $75 | Check the loan schedule separately from the account credit. Merchant gives credit directly | The store gives $60 in store credit, a gift card, or cash directly to a PayPal shopper. | $75 | The shopper still has the separate PayPal plan. Afterpay applies the refund | Afterpay applies the $60 in its published example. | $15 | Installments four and three are canceled. The second falls to $15. Affirm marks a partial refund | The transaction record still shows a positive loan balance. | Read the actual balance | Open the current schedule before quoting an amount or due date. ### Tell the shopper where the refund landed Start with the refund amount and the provider record. If posting is still pending, say what your team sent and when you can check again. If PayPal shows the credit on the plan, mention the current balance and direct the shopper to the schedule for the next payment. If it landed in their PayPal account, make clear that the installment plan still has its own balance. Use the procedure for the provider on the order. Afterpay’s US guidance specifically prohibits paying cash directly for amounts the shopper paid to Afterpay. Provider references: PayPal US Pay in 4 refunds, Afterpay US merchant refund instructions, Affirm transaction states. (https://www.paypal.com/us/cshelp/article/how-does-a-merchant-refund-work-for-my-pay-in-4-plan-help652, https://www.afterpay.com/en-US/help-merchant/4708271751193-How-do-I-process-a-refund, https://docs.affirm.com/developers/docs/transaction-states) Download the refund routing comparison (CSV) to keep the provider record and the plan balance separate when you write your reply. (downloads/bnpl-refund-routing.csv) ## Methodology and Sources We compare the annual approval series in Figure 2 and footnote 13 of CFPB’s January 13, 2025 report with its separate Figure 3 discussion of counteroffers. The source uses administrative data from six BNPL firms covering 2019 to 2022. Annual differences are subtraction of published rounded percentages. We retain the report’s approximate counteroffer comparison without combining potentially different analysis samples into a fabricated exact rejection rate. The source period is Published January 13, 2025; administrative data 2019 to 2022. Independent calculations were completed in November 2026 and use the formulas shown above. ## Glossary Application: A request for finance, distinct from a completed store order. Approval: The lender’s recorded approval outcome under its stated definition. Counteroffer: An offer of revised financing terms. Down payment: The amount required upfront under the financing terms. Accepted offer: An offer the shopper has agreed to continue with. Authorization: A payment-provider decision allowing a payment attempt to proceed. Percentage point: The absolute difference between two percentages. Administrative series: Statistics calculated from operational records supplied to the researcher. ## Sources Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later and Other Unsecured Debt (https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_BNPL_Report_2025_01.pdf) Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later and Other Unsecured Debt (https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/consumer-use-of-buy-now-pay-later-and-other-unsecured-debt/) Check the source figures The data file retains source labels, values, populations and limitations for this analysis.